
Despite the continuing debate between Matthean and Markan priorists, some form of the widely-accepted Two-Source Hypothesis seems necessary for a proper understanding of the synoptic relationships. The Two-Source Hypothesis as generally conceived, however, cannot cover the evidence of dependence and interdependence found in the Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke. The same must be said for the theory of Matthean priority.
Both Markan and Matthean priorists are guilty of trying to solve the synoptic problem by over reliance on evidence for the interdependence of the Synoptic Gospels. These theorists’ basic error stems from their failure to recognize the necessity of positing the existence of a document other than Q, a document that is not completely present in any of the canonical Gospels. The interdependence of the Synoptic Gospels is a fact from which no theory of origins can escape, but the evidence of dependence on an additional document no longer extant, yet known to each of the synoptic writers, demands an adequate literary explanation.
Very few twentieth-century synoptic theorists can be said to have wrestled seriously with the question of whether a Mark-like, extra-canonical authority may not be necessary to explain unsolved problems of synoptic relationships. Instead, the tendency has been to abandon all hope of finding a literary solution.[1]
Premium Members
If you are not a Premium Member, please consider becoming one starting at $10/month (paid monthly) or only $5/month (paid annually):
One Time Purchase Rather Than Membership
Rather than a membership, you may also purchase access to this entire page for $1.99 USD. (If you do not have an account select "Register & Purchase.")
- [1] Cf. Otto A. Piper, “The Origin of the Gospel Pattern,” JBL 78 (1959): 115. ↩
Comments 12
Pingback: The Priority of Luke: An Exposition of Robert Lindsey’s Solution to the Synoptic Problem | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: Spontaneous Growth Parable | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: Chickens and the Cultural Context of the Gospels | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: Mustard Seed and Starter Dough Parables – Test site for JPs new search engine
Pingback: Jesus and a Canaanite Woman | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: William Lockton, Robert Lindsey’s Forerunner | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: The Major Importance of the “Minor” Agreements | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: Introduction to “The Life of Yeshua: A Suggested Reconstruction” | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: Evidence of an Editor’s Hand in Two Instances of Mark’s Account of Jesus’ Last Week? | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: The Writings of Robert L. Lindsey | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: From Luke to Mark to Matthew: A Discussion of the Sources of Markan “Pick-ups” and the Use of a Basic Non-canonical Source by All the Synoptists | JerusalemPerspective.com Online
Pingback: The Times of the Gentiles and the Redemption of Jerusalem | JerusalemPerspective.com Online